Invoice Payment Disputes & Dilution while factoring
Invoice disputes pop up all the time, and in factoring, they can put stress on the relationship, especially if the disputes are big or happen often. That’s why factors don’t advance the full invoice amount upfront. By holding a portion back, they make sure the discount fee is covered and there’s a buffer for any shortfall in payment. In the factoring world, this is known as dilution or an offset. Dilution can be managed when it’s expected, but an offset usually comes as a surprise.
Let’s cover dilution first.
Experienced factors who understand your industry know what’s reasonable when it comes to advance rates. They can strike the right balance between giving you cash up-front and protecting both sides against dilution.
If dilution is common in your industry, factors are usually ready for it. But when unexpected dilution shows up, it can catch them off guard and often impact funding until the issue gets cleared up. To stay within the agreed formula, factors lean heavily on the cash reserve account.
When a factor knows that significant dilution is on the horizon, they typically take two steps:
- Hold back cash reserve releases to build a balance that can absorb the dilution.
- Offset with new fundings, though this is really just pushing the problem forward, since it’s essentially a journal entry to plug the gap.
Most dilution factors see comes from suppliers into big box retail but it can be tucked into any supplier agreement.
Common Retailer Discounts & Deductions
Key Takeaway: Between trade allowances, compliance chargebacks, and post-sale adjustments, suppliers may see 5–20% dilution of invoice value in major retail channels. This is exactly why factors calculate advance rates conservatively and why suppliers need to carefully manage deductions.
When there’s known dilution, factors use a simple formula to figure out the advance rate: they take two times the dilution and then add five percent on top.
Advance Rate Formula with Known Dilution Example:
Item Value
Invoice Amount $100,000
Known Dilution 7.5%
Formula (7.5% × 2) = 15% + 5% = 20% Accured Reserve
Calculation Holdback
Advance Rate 100% − 20% = 80%
Advance Amount $100,000 × 80% = $80,00
Let’s now discuss offsets.
Dilution is something you can plan for, but offsets are a different story. Offsets are those short-payments or non-payments that come out of left field. Just when the factor is expecting the customer’s payment to arrive as usual, a call or email shows up saying otherwise. What makes it even tougher is that sometimes the client already knew there was an issue with the payment but didn’t share it with the factor, which only adds to the surprise.
Factoring companies know that dilution and offsets are part of the business. What really matters is how openly clients communicate when an issue comes up. When clients are upfront about a problem, it shows good faith and gives both sides the chance to work together on a practical solution that keeps the relationship honest.